Calculus: Smallest hypotenuse in a right-angled triangle with a known area?

If you have a right-angled triangle with area = S, which one would have the smallest hypotenuse?

Let x and y be the legs of the right triangle. Then the hypotenuse z satisfies

z² = x² + y².

Since z>0, minimizing z² will minimize z.

The area of the triangle is

S = (1/2)xy

2S/x = y

z² = x² + (2S/x)².

So find a minimum for the function

f(x) = x² + (2S/x)²:

f’(x) = 2x + 4S^2 (-2 x^(-3))
= 2x – 8S² x^(-3).

This does not exist when x=0, but if x=0 we don’t have a triangle. Set to 0:

0 = 2x – 8S² x^(-3)
Multiply through by x^3:
0 = 2x^4 – 8S²
0 = x^4 – 4S²
4S² = x^4
[4S²]^(1/4) = x
√(2S) = x.

(You need to perform the second derivative test to show x = √(2S) gives a minimum.)

Then y = 2S/x = 2S/√(2S) = √(2S),

and

z² = (√(2S))² + (√(2S))²
= 2S + 2S
= 4S

–>

z = 2√S is the smallest hypotenuse.

Hope this helps.

♣ ♣

One Response to “Calculus: Smallest hypotenuse in a right-angled triangle with a known area?”

  1. Let x and y be the legs of the right triangle. Then the hypotenuse z satisfies

    z² = x² + y².

    Since z>0, minimizing z² will minimize z.

    The area of the triangle is

    S = (1/2)xy

    2S/x = y

    z² = x² + (2S/x)².

    So find a minimum for the function

    f(x) = x² + (2S/x)²:

    f’(x) = 2x + 4S^2 (-2 x^(-3))
    = 2x – 8S² x^(-3).

    This does not exist when x=0, but if x=0 we don’t have a triangle. Set to 0:

    0 = 2x – 8S² x^(-3)
    Multiply through by x^3:
    0 = 2x^4 – 8S²
    0 = x^4 – 4S²
    4S² = x^4
    [4S²]^(1/4) = x
    √(2S) = x.

    (You need to perform the second derivative test to show x = √(2S) gives a minimum.)

    Then y = 2S/x = 2S/√(2S) = √(2S),

    and

    z² = (√(2S))² + (√(2S))²
    = 2S + 2S
    = 4S

    –>

    z = 2√S is the smallest hypotenuse.

    Hope this helps.

    ♣ ♣
    References :

Leave a Reply